April 16, 2012

Friendship is Hard (and How to Make it Easier)

It seems I am not the only one who struggles with friendship. After my nursing bra post, women shared their own friendship woes with me or simply affirmed my "friendship is hard" statement. We're all in the same boat, it seems. Too, your responses still have me thinking. Aside from the logistical issues of marriage, children, and work responsibilities that make connecting difficult, why are adult friendships so hard?

Thinking on this question, I was reminded of Dietrich Bonhoeffer's thoughts on Christian community in Life Together: 
It is easily forgotten that the fellowship of Christian brethren is a gift of grace, a gift of the Kingdom of God that any day may be taken from us, that the time that still separates us from utter loneliness may be brief indeed. Therefore, let him who until now has had the privilege of living a common Christian life with other Christians praise God on his knees and declare: It is grace, nothing but grace, that we are allowed to live in community with Christian brethren.
In other words, we are not guaranteed or entitled to heart friends. They are gifts of grace, and when we catch glimpses of sisterly love, we must receive it as such with deep gratitude. 
Bonhoeffer doesn't say it, but his words imply it: friendship does not come easily. We tend to believe the myth that friendship should be easy, requires little effort, or, most debilitating, that we're the only one who is having such a hard time with friendship.

Why doesn't God make it easier on us? After all, He calls us to live in community with others, to let our love for one another be a light to those in darkness. I prayed to Him for years for a good friend where I lived, but didn't see His answer. I believe He allowed those seasons of friendship dryness so that I would not put anyone else in His place, so that I would rely on Him to meet my deepest needs. Through that season, I also developed an eye and a compassion for the women standing on the fringe longing for connection.

But I also don't think I recognized how He answered my prayers. I wanted that one, catch-all friend, like the best friend I had growing up. I hadn't learned yet that the rules of friendship dramatically change after college. Whereas I once lived with friends and moved through life in one big circle of love, adult friendships require so much more effort, time, and breaking through insecurities (What's up with that? That's fodder for another post). Thinking my adult friendships would look like my high-school or college friendship, I didn't have eyes to see friends right in front of me. I put way too many parameters on friendship: they have to go to my church, they have to have the same-age kids, I have to like their husband, they can't be in a different life stage, they have to be on the same page spiritually.

Too often, I also just waited around, assuming they would come to me if they wanted to be my friend. When we moved from that town, I saw it all so clearly, all the opportunities I missed to know and be known. By God's grace, I got to start over and approach friendship differently.

Do you need to change your approach? Do you need to release your ideal picture of friendship and ask God to show you the potential friends right in front of you? Initiate, be curious, practice openness to people different from you or different from the idea you have for what a friend should be.

Soon you will see relationships developing with women of all different life stages and personalities and ages, all gifts of grace from God.


---
The winner of Shauna Pilgreen's book for moms and their teenage daughters, The Same Page, is April Pettefer who entered the giveaway with this comment: "Since I have four daughters, this will be a great resource!" Congratulations, April! Please email me through the Contact page above and I'll get you the book.

16 comments:

guest said...

So encouraging and truth filled.  I keep asking for that one heart friend but then I find friendship in unexpected places like the gym.  I enjoy having friends who aren't in ministry or at our church or who don't have kids.  It keeps my head out of the gutter, gives me perspective on my life stage and helps me to not complain or whine about the stage I am in.   Some of my closest friends don't have kids.  Also, I enjoy knowing women whose kids are older.  I like hearing their stories about their kids and knowing that soon mine will be gone.  

I just don't know what do with friendships when ministry gets messy (like people don't like decisions made at the church or decisions that your husband made or don't think he is doing enough).  How do you keeps friends at the church?  How do you press on?  For me it's hard not to believe that everyone feels that way and then I get wrapped up in a pity party.  

Ruth H said...

Thank you for these timely posts on friendship. This really is one of the most difficult areas of my life, and it is nice to feel a little less alone in the struggles to keep persevering in prayer and be open to whatever God has in store.

Melanie said...

This was inspiring.  And also confirms my belief that we should start a commune.  I think if we all milk goats and knit knickers together we will be ensured a life of enduring friendship:)  (Not that life would be any easier...wool knickers....itchy!)

Christine Hoover said...

Ruth said:
Thank you for these timely posts on friendship. This really is one of the most difficult areas of my life, and it is nice to feel a little less alone in the struggles to keep persevering in prayer and be open to whatever God has in store. 

Christine Hoover said...

I can always count on you to be my make-me-laugh friend, Melanie. I would happily move into a commune with you because of all the great food you cook.

Christine Hoover said...

If I were in an unhealthy church (as far as how people relate to the staff and their wives or what they expect from staff and wives), I would primarily pursue relationships outside the church.

That said, I would not allow what people think (or what I perceive people think) to keep me from 1) being myself and 2) becoming jaded and closed off. Sometimes this takes us forgiving hurts and offenses, intentional or not, and not letting the enemy use those wounds to keep us isolated and emotionally paralyzed. 

Sometimes when I want to go inside myself, I remind myself that everyone else probably feels like I do. Meaning, they want to know and be known too. I try to remind myself that people often wound from their own wounds or because they simply don't have all the information that I have or that my husband has when he made a decision. It helps me forgive and not respond from my own hurt.

All that to say, yes, it's hard. Yes, we will experience hurts. But we must press on.

Melany Williams said...

I totally agree with you about the need to reevaluate our expectations for who our friends will be. As I mentioned in a comment on the previous post, I'm serving on the Reservation, where Christians are a minority. The Reservation is bordered by small rural towns, where most of the twenty-somethings leave for college, and don't come back unless they're getting married to a rancher. I've gotten to know a few girls recently, but until then, I really didn't know many single Christian girls who'd fit my customary 'friend demographic.' :) But I've been so blessed by the friendships I developed outside of that demographic, one being my pastor's wife, who is about the same age as my mother (! :) and another a young wife who just had a baby girl. But I'll attest to two things you mentioned- I had to learn not to be a 'one-person friend,' as adult women have more responsibilities to balance along with their friendships, and I had to be willing to let go of the facade that I had it all together on my own. You're right about that being a somewhat post-college phenomenon-- probably due to the newness of independence and our desire to show that we can 'handle' adult life with it's responsibilities. Once we work so hard to build up that impression, we're slow to let down our guard and let people see behind our pretense at perfection-- ESPECIALLY if we're in ministry. But learning to do so is part of the maturing process, as well as the relationship-building process, as you mentioned. 

Christine Hoover said...

Great thoughts, Melany.

Heather said...

Thank you. This is exactly what I'm struggling with right now, and I needed to hear this. 

Dianne Rigdon said...

Thank you! Thank you for the article at Desiring God about motherhood which led me here. I was reading a later post and wondered to myself if you would have any advice about friendship and I scrolled down to see this discussion. Sweet! :) After my mom passed, I realized she had been my only friend for a very long time. I had a loooooong dry spell and looked and looked for that special someone to take her place. And of course there is no one who can. After many years, I finally have a circle of heart friends. I have many different friends with whom I can enjoy my time, but my "circle" friends are special. However, we have gotten past the honeymoon stage (LOL) and it has gotten a lot harder. I find myself thinking "if I would have known THAT about this one" or "I never knew that one could be like THAT" and of course I, myself also fall short of being the perfect friend. I am just glad to know it's supposed to be hard, in a way, and that I can look at it in a very different way, self last. Also, one of my very good friends is a pastor's wife and I know she has a special set of struggles and responsibilities to go with it. I wondered if you, as a pastor's wife, could share what is helpful to YOU in a friend. 

Christine Hoover said...

Dianne, welcome to the blog! I'm thankful you came over from Desiring God. I love your question about what is helpful for pastor's wives in friendship. I'd like to turn it into a blog post, if you don't mind. What do you think?

Andrea said...

I have always been on the outskirts of groups since I was young, being an introvert by nature crowds tend to overwhelm me.  God has also given me a gift in helping me to see the women on the fringes of groups and I tend to reach for them the most.  You just never know if you open yourself up to anybody He may provide a friend that you never would have guessed could have been.  One of my best friends is so unlike me, but we are sisters in Christ and that is all that matters. 

Karen said...

Thank you for this insight. I am movIng into a season of dryness. Through the addition of two special needs children into our family in two years, a falling out with two friends in that same time and two -soon to be three-friends relocating due to job changes, I will have "lost" all of my closest friends by the end of next month. I was sitting here be resentful and angry with God for stripping me of these life affirming friendships and taking my support system away. You have reminded first that I need to have an attitude of gratitude for the times I had with these precious women. More importantly, I have been re-directed back to my true lifeline and my one steadfast support system. God used you today to minister to to me, a total stranger - I love that about God.,

Christine Hoover said...

God is good, not only to care about our concerns, but to use small things to encourage us. I'm thankful He did that for you today.

Jamie said...

I keep coming back and reviewing your "What I've learned in Ministry" lists. It's like there's a different point that ministers to me weekly. Today it was this post on friendship. I think I just need to print your list out. As I've commented before, sometimes just knowing that I'm not alone in these challenges as a church planter's wife is the best comfort.

Christine Hoover said...

I'm so thankful that it's been helpful to you, Jamie. I sometimes have to go back and read the posts myself, especially this one on friendship, just to remember what God has taught me. Your words were an encouragement to me today.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...